An allocation is Pareto efficient if no feasible change benefits someone without harming anyone else. This criterion does not rank fairness or resolve tradeoffs when a change creates winners and losers.
Hypothetical utility indices, with no interpersonal comparison implied. (4,4) Pareto-improves on (3,3). Every point on uA + uB = 10 is efficient, including (1,9) and (5,5); efficiency alone does not rank their fairness.