Marxism
Saved & recent

Determinate negation

Also called: Specific negation

Determinate negation is a Hegelian idea used in dialectical traditions: overcoming something through its particular tensions produces a specific result, rather than an empty rejection of everything. The new form retains a relation to what it transforms. What is rejected and what is carried forward must therefore be explained.

Marx’s discussion of property illustrates this pattern. He envisages overcoming capitalist ownership while retaining developed cooperation and productive capacities, rather than returning to isolated small producers. This is a philosophical account of transformation, not proof that the forecast must occur. Determinate negation is related to sublation, but should not be reduced to a slogan that every change is progress.

Read first
Dialectics
Related
Communism
Further reading
owner single ownership route common decision routes same tools and cooperation
The envisaged transformation changes ownership while retaining cooperative productive capacities.

View in the full Marxism collection