Marxism
Saved & recent

Exploitation and justice

The debate about exploitation and justice asks how a structural account of surplus appropriation connects to a moral criticism. Explaining where profit comes from does not by itself specify why an arrangement is unjust. Different Marxists emphasize domination, unequal opportunities, ownership or claims to the products of labor.

An employee might knowingly accept a contract while having few viable alternatives. Consent, productive contribution and the fairness of the background conditions are distinct questions. Cohen argues that condemning exploitation need not depend on Marx’s labor theory of value. Marx’s own criticism of abstract appeals to fair distribution complicates the debate: an account of justice must also examine how production and ownership are organized.

Read first
Surplus value
Related
Surplus value, Labor-power, Analytical Marxism, Relations of production
Further reading
employment contract consent? available alternatives? who receives the benefits?
Consent, alternatives and the distribution of benefits pose different questions about one arrangement.

View in the full Marxism collection