Marxism
Saved & recent

Instrumental reason

Also called: Instrumental rationality

Instrumental reason evaluates how efficiently a chosen goal can be achieved. Horkheimer’s critique concerns its dominance: reasoning becomes skilled at selecting means while questions about whether the goal is good, just or worth pursuing receive less attention.

A delivery system could optimize the shortest route without asking whether its deadline permits safe working conditions. The calculation may be correct while the purpose and constraints remain questionable. This distinction does not make practical calculation useless. It asks that calculation remain answerable to reflection on ends, human needs and the social relations in which apparently neutral technical decisions operate.

Related
Culture industry, Immanent critique, Alienation
Further reading
Max Horkheimer — Eclipse of Reason, “Means and Ends” (1947)
R start drop-off rest stop solid · direct route dashed · rest stop choose deadline,rest and safety limits optimize withinthose choices
Hypothetical dispatch: choosing a deadline and rest constraints is a different question from optimizing a route. No travel times are measured.

View in the full Marxism collection