Marxism
Saved & recent

Overdetermination

For Althusser, a social contradiction exists through the other conditions that shape it. Economic conflict, political institutions, inherited divisions and international pressures do not merely sit beside one another; their interaction gives a particular conflict its form and possible force.

A fictional wage dispute could change character when a transport shortage, an election and a housing struggle meet. None is simply an extra item added to an otherwise unchanged dispute. This example illustrates the method rather than predicting a revolution. Overdetermination challenges explanations that derive every outcome directly from one economic cause, while retaining Althusser’s argument about the structuring role of production relations.

Read first
Contradiction
Related
Contradiction, Historical materialism, Relative autonomy
Further reading
Louis Althusser — Contradiction and Overdetermination (1962)
housing transport elections wage dispute changed dispute interacting conditions
Hypothetical dispute: interacting conditions change the form of a conflict.

View in the full Marxism collection