Marxism
Saved & recent

Second contradiction of capitalism

Also called: Second contradiction

James O’Connor’s second contradiction concerns capital undermining its own conditions of production, including environments, labor-power and infrastructure. Actions that save an individual business money can degrade shared conditions and eventually raise costs elsewhere in the economy.

For example, a hypothetical factory may avoid treatment costs by polluting water that other producers need. Later purification costs can offset or exceed the original saving. The argument concerns a possible feedback into profitability as well as social and ecological harm. Harm does not always generate that feedback promptly: costs can be displaced onto communities, future generations or places with little power to resist.

Related
Crisis tendencies, Metabolic rift, Social reproduction
Further reading
James O’Connor — On the Two Contradictions of Capitalism (1991)
upstream firm treatment step bypass saving shared river community harm purification cost possible higher production costs
Hypothetical cost shifting can damage the shared conditions on which production depends.

View in the full Marxism collection