Marxism
Saved & recent

Transformation problem

The transformation problem concerns the relationship between labor values and prices of production when competition tends to equalize profit rates across industries. In Marx’s account, sectors with different mixes of machinery and living labor can receive profits different from the surplus-value produced within them.

The difficulty is not merely that shop prices fluctuate. Inputs are themselves purchased at prices, so a consistent account must explain input valuation as well as output prices and aggregate totals. Marx addresses the starting problem in Capital, Volume III; later critics and defenders propose different formulations and solutions. A diagram of profit redistribution is therefore an aid to the question, not proof that the controversy has been resolved.

Read first
Constant and variable capital, Value
Related
Value, Constant and variable capital, Surplus value, Analytical Marxism
Further reading
Karl Marx — Capital, Volume III, Chapter 9
machinery-intensive sector labor-intensive sector value accounting competitive price setting average-profit constraint output prices input valuation input valuation
Input prices feed back into production costs, which a consistent transformation account must address.

View in the full Marxism collection