Science fiction
Saved & recent

Underdetermination

Also called: Competing explanations, Evidence underdetermination

Novel example: The Telling — Ursula K. Le Guin

Underdetermination occurs when available evidence fits more than one explanation. The explanations need not be equally plausible, and new evidence may separate them. The key distinction is between having an explanation that could work and having enough evidence to show that it is the correct one.

In the chapter-five excerpt of Ursula K. Le Guin’s The Telling, Sutty considers competing accounts of a puzzling observation without settling it. The scene makes the pressure to explain visible. A useful reading habit is to keep the original observation separate from details added by a preferred interpretation.

Related
Epistemic humility, Paradigm shift, Alien artifact
Further reading
Ursula K. Le Guin — The Telling, chapter five excerpt
observed signal hypothesis A hypothesis B hypothesis C proposed test outcome for A outcome for B potential distinction: A versus B
One observation can fit several explanations; a discriminating test may narrow them.

View in the full Science fiction collection